top of page
Search

When the Plan No Longer Fits: Learning Crisis Leadership from Those Who've Lived It

Nov 10
4 min read

Dutchess County Emergency Response Center sign with solar panels and address 392 Creek Road

Meridian's inaugural executive seminar offered emergency management professionals a rare opportunity to learn from veteran FEMA leaders who have spent decades responding to major disasters.


What happens when the emergency plan you've spent years developing meets a crisis that refuses to follow it? Information is incomplete. Resources are stretched. Public expectations are rising. Decisions carry consequences, and everyone is looking to leadership for answers. Few understand those moments better than the emergency management professionals who have spent their careers navigating some of the nation's most consequential disasters.


On Sept. 29-30, 2026, Meridian Strategic Services brought that experience into the classroom with its inaugural Executive Leadership During Crisis: Leading Beyond the Plan seminar at the Dutchess County Emergency Response Center in Poughkeepsie, New York. The two-day seminar offered participants a rare opportunity to learn directly from two former FEMA leaders whose combined careers span more than eight decades of public safety, emergency management, and disaster response. Real emergencies, difficult decisions, and decades of experience leading in high-stakes situations shaped their lessons. Through this seminar, Meridian is helping ensure that knowledge reaches the next generation of emergency management leaders.


"We created this seminar to offer a truly unique experience in the emergency management profession," said seminar organizer and Meridian President Seamus Leary. "It provided experienced emergency managers with the opportunity to engage with peers from different organizations and learn from instructors who have decades of experience leading large, multi-agency teams during highly complex disasters," he continued.

 

Decades of Experience. Lessons That Matter.

Thomas "Farge" Fargione and Peter Rennert led the seminar. They are two former FEMA leaders whose careers have placed them at the center of complex emergency management operations. Fargione, a former FEMA National Incident Management Assistance Team leader, brought nearly 50 years of experience spanning law enforcement, fire service, emergency medical services, and major disaster operations. Rennert, a former FEMA Type 1 Operations Section chief, brought more than 28 years of federal emergency management experience, including extensive disaster deployments and developing advanced emergency management training.

 

Together, they offered something textbooks or emergency plans cannot fully capture: the perspective that comes from years of making consequential decisions under extraordinary circumstances. Their experience grounded discussions of strategic decision-making, risk management, crisis communications, organizational coordination, and leadership under pressure. For participants, the opportunity extended beyond learning established emergency management principles. It offered insight into how experienced leaders think, adapt, and decide when familiar procedures meet unfamiliar circumstances.


When the Scenario Changes, So Must the Thinking

Throughout the seminar, realistic crisis scenarios challenged participants to think beyond established procedures. A hazardous materials train derailment introduced conflicting reports, unknown chemicals, and growing public concern. A cyberattack on a regional fuel pipeline raised questions about essential services, competing priorities, and limited resources. A catastrophic hurricane scenario followed a major disaster from pre-landfall preparations through immediate response, stabilization, and long-term recovery, with new complications emerging as conditions evolved. Each scenario raised questions emergency management leaders may one day face.


How do you make decisions when critical information remains uncertain? How do you establish priorities when resources are limited? How do you maintain public confidence while managing operational challenges? And perhaps most importantly, how do you recognize when an established plan needs to evolve?


"The highlight for me was watching participants challenge their assumptions. After nearly 50 years in this field, I've learned that circumstances will change, often when you least expect it," shared Fargione. "If we can help the next generation of leaders recognize that and think more strategically, we're passing along something valuable." 

 

"What surprised me was how quickly participants began connecting the scenarios to situations they had faced in their own careers," Fargione explained. "They understood that the decisions we were discussing weren't theoretical. These are the kinds of challenges leaders encounter when disasters become more complicated than anyone anticipated."


Passing Experience to the Next Generation

One of the seminar's central themes was the distinction between managing an emergency and leading through a crisis. Emergency plans establish roles, responsibilities, and procedures. But complex crises can introduce unfamiliar conditions, competing priorities, and consequences that extend far beyond the initial incident.


The curriculum examined the relationship between strategy and tactics, shared situational awareness, and senior leaders' responsibility to evaluate and communicate risk. Discussions also addressed crisis communications, organizational trust, leadership fatigue, and the challenges of sustaining effective leadership during prolonged incidents.


The hurricane scenario extended into long-term recovery, when communities may continue facing displacement, damaged infrastructure, economic disruption, and mounting expectations months after the initial disaster. These are precisely the kinds of challenges that experienced disaster leaders understand from years in the field. For Meridian, connecting that experience with current and emerging emergency management professionals is essential to strengthening the profession's future.


"The highlight was seeing them connect the lessons to their own leadership responsibilities," Rennert explained. "We've learned a great deal from the disasters we've managed over the years. Being able to share that experience and help others prepare for the decisions they'll face is one of the most rewarding parts of teaching."  

 

"What stood out to me was how participants approached the strategic decisions," Rennert continued. "They were willing to consider different perspectives and examine how quickly priorities can change during a complex incident."


Building the Next Generation of Crisis Leaders

Meridian's inaugural seminar represents an important step in its commitment to strengthening crisis readiness, executive leadership, and organizational resilience. By bringing experienced disaster leaders together with emergency management professionals, Meridian is creating opportunities to preserve institutional knowledge, share hard-earned lessons,

and strengthen the judgment required to lead during high-consequence incidents.


As Meridian considers future executive training opportunities, the mission remains clear: Help today's and tomorrow's leaders prepare for the decisions that cannot always be anticipated, rehearsed, or written into a plan. Because when the plan no longer fits, experience matters. And so does passing it on.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page